Miners Challenge Key Provisions in Zimbabwe Mines Bill

Published:

Miners and other industry stakeholders have challenged several provisions of Zimbabwe’s proposed Mines and Minerals Bill, raising concerns over the protection of mineral rights, exploration licensing, land access and the recognition of artisanal mining during parliamentary public hearings in Harare on Tuesday, Mining Zimbabwe can report.

By Rudairo Mapuranga

The submissions highlighted potential implications of the proposed legislation for mineral exploration, investment and the administration of mining rights, with participants calling for safeguards against excessive administrative discretion and regulatory requirements that could disadvantage smaller operators.

Shakemore Fundira, representing the Prospectors Association, called for stronger protection of the legal rights associated with mineral prospecting and greater clarity over the recognition and functions of professionals involved in acquiring and demarcating mining ground.

Fundira’s submission focused on the relationship between State ownership of mineral resources and the legal rights granted to individuals and companies to prospect for and develop mineral deposits.

He argued that the proposed legislation should protect these rights and ensure that administrative powers governing their allocation, reservation and cancellation are guided by clear statutory criteria.

A major concern was the proposed replacement of the existing Register of Approved Prospectors with a Register of Staking Agents under Clauses 23 to 29.

Fundira argued that the change should not undermine the statutory functions and professional recognition associated with approved prospectors, particularly their established role in mineral exploration and the acquisition of mining rights.

Under the proposed framework, staking agents would undertake the physical or virtual pegging and demarcation of mining locations, while prospectors would hold exclusive prospecting licences. Existing approved prospectors would be required to meet new registration requirements to continue operating as staking agents.

Fundira called for the preservation of prospectors’ practical functions, including access to legally available ground and the ability to undertake exploration across sufficiently large areas.

He also raised concerns about the exclusive prospecting licensing framework, arguing that its provisions should accommodate the geological and practical requirements of exploration projects.

On the administration of mining rights, he recommended clearly published criteria governing licence reservations and cancellations, written decisions and transparent procedures through which affected parties could challenge administrative decisions.

He further called for secure access to cadastral information for registered prospectors, arguing that reliable information on land and mining rights was essential for exploration planning and preventing disputes over mining ground.

Exploration licensing also featured prominently in submissions by another participant, Nkosi Bhebhe, who questioned the effectiveness of the existing Exclusive Prospecting Order (EPO) system.

Bhebhe argued that EPOs, which were intended to facilitate the discovery of new mineral deposits, had in some instances allowed large areas to remain under exclusive control without sufficient exploration activity.

He cited more than 35,000 hectares associated with iron ore exploration and said Parliament had previously been told that only about 40 of more than 300 EPOs had been utilised.

He called for greater accountability in the administration of exploration rights and questioned whether the proposed licensing framework would provide sufficient time and geographical flexibility for meaningful exploration.

Under the Bill, an exclusive prospecting licence is valid for 12 months, within which the holder must identify and stake an area of up to 40 contiguous hectares within the relevant mining province.

Bhebhe argued that the combination of the time limit and area restriction could constrain exploration programmes, particularly for minerals such as lithium, where identifying economically viable deposits may require extensive geological investigation.

He called for a more practical exploration framework supported by clear work programmes, appropriate relinquishment requirements and provisions allowing exploration projects to develop without unnecessary administrative restrictions.

Bhebhe also proposed that exploration reports be shared with relevant Government ministries and institutions, including those responsible for mining, environmental management, agriculture, land administration, local government, finance and industry.

He argued that wider access to exploration information would improve coordination in mineral resource planning and reduce conflicts between competing land uses.

The participant further questioned the qualifications of Provincial Mining Directors (PMDs), arguing that officials exercising powers over mining rights, disputes and penalties should possess appropriate technical qualifications and experience.

He proposed that ministerial decisions on mining matters should be informed by written technical advice, with reasons published whenever the Minister departs from such advice.

Land access and property rights

Land access and the protection of property rights emerged as another contentious issue.

Bhebhe challenged Clause 37, particularly the provision that prevents a landholder who refuses a miner or prospector access to their property from subsequently obtaining mining rights over the same ground for ten years, unless written permission is obtained from the earlier rights holder.

He argued that although mineral resources are vested in the President, landholders also have constitutionally protected interests in their homes, crops and graves.

Bhebhe said the provision unfairly penalised landholders for exercising their rights and referred to the Parliamentary Legal Committee’s earlier objection that the restriction could violate Section 71 of the Constitution, which protects property rights.

He called for negotiations, mediation and compensation arrangements before access disputes are determined, alongside safeguards against the forced occupation of homesteads.

The concerns come amid continuing debate over the balance between mineral rights and landholder interests, with Mines and Mining Development Minister Polite Kambamura having indicated earlier this month that proposed amendments to Clauses 37 and 39 would address aspects of the relationship between mining rights and land administration.

Artisanal miners seek formal recognition

Meanwhile, a representative of the Women in Gemstones Association of Zimbabwe (WIGAZ) called for the proposed legislation to formally recognise artisanal miners as a distinct category, arguing that the current framework does not adequately reflect their circumstances.

She said the Bill’s definition of small-scale mining did not sufficiently accommodate artisanal operators, who often work with limited capital, smaller workforces and less sophisticated equipment.

The representative argued that applying similar regulatory and compliance requirements across artisanal, small-scale and large-scale operations could impose disproportionate costs on smaller miners.

She proposed separate definitions for artisanal, small-scale and large-scale miners, supported by differentiated licensing fees, simplified registration procedures and compliance requirements based on the scale and risks of mining activities.

The submission also called for a practical formalisation framework that would provide artisanal miners with access to technical training, affordable finance, shared processing facilities and technical support.

She proposed that artisanal miners could organise themselves into groups or syndicates operating in designated areas, with clear registration arrangements and pathways to grow into larger mining operations without losing their legal standing.

The representative also urged that the Mining Industry Loan Fund for small-scale miners support locally driven mineral value addition, arguing that Zimbabwe should retain more value from its mineral resources.

She further questioned Clause 308, which requires anyone discovering precious stones to notify the Provincial Mining Director within ten days of the discovery.

The representative said people living in gemstone-producing communities may not always distinguish between precious and semi-precious stones, potentially exposing ordinary residents to legal difficulties when they encounter such minerals around their homes or properties.

She cited communities where gemstones occur naturally and argued that the legislation should provide greater clarity on the notification requirement and the distinction between the different categories of stones.

The representative said artisanal miners, commonly referred to as makorokoza, had made a significant contribution to Zimbabwe’s gold production and deserved explicit recognition within the country’s mining laws.

The absence of a separate definition for artisanal miners has also been raised by the Parliamentary Legal Committee, which previously questioned whether their exclusion from the Bill’s definitions could result in unfair discrimination against operators based on their economic circumstances.

Communities raise social and environmental concerns

Traditional and religious stakeholders also raised concerns about the social consequences of mining, particularly community displacement, the relocation of graves and the need to observe traditional consultation procedures before mining activities commence.

Farai Mapfumo, Member of Parliament for Headlands Constituency in Manicaland and Acting Chairperson of Team B conducting the hearings on behalf of the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Mines and Mining Development, said the existing legislation needed to be modernised to reflect changes in the country’s economic, social and environmental circumstances.

Mapfumo said the Mines and Minerals Act, which dates back to 1961, no longer adequately addressed the realities of the modern mining industry.

“The laws no longer speak to the times that we are conducting our mining,” he told Mining Zimbabwe.

He cited population growth, the expansion of agriculture and the effects of global warming and climate change as factors increasing competition for land on which mining activities take place.

Mapfumo said economic submissions had highlighted the importance of local mineral value addition and beneficiation in increasing national output and Government revenue.

He also raised questions about Zimbabwe’s cadastral administration, asking whether the country had one national system capable of coordinating mining, agricultural and urban land records or whether different institutions maintained separate systems.

He described the issue as particularly important to the formulation of the proposed legislation, which introduces a Mining Cadastre Register for recording mining rights and titles.

Mapfumo said Parliament had recorded the contributions, with some participants submitting written documents during the hearing while others would forward their submissions to the Clerk of Parliament.

He said the objective was to develop people-centred legislation that facilitates mineral extraction and increases national revenue without compromising the interests of future generations.

“It has to be sustainable mining which is both economically beneficial and environmentally friendly,” he said.

The public consultations are running from November 17 to 22, 2026, across the country’s ten provinces, providing mining companies, industry associations, prospectors, small-scale miners, landholders and communities an opportunity to contribute to legislation that will shape the future administration of Zimbabwe’s mineral resources.

Related articles

spot_img

Recent articles

spot_img